Make a Payment

Make a Payment

Pay Your Insurance Bill

Below is information about paying your bill directly through your insurance carrier. If available, a billing phone number is also included should you wish to make a payment by phone instead.

If your company is not listed, if you need additional help, or if you have other billing issues, please call your local Bearingstar representative.

  • Arbella Insurance Group

    (This includes the underwriting companies of Arbella Mutual, Arbella Protection, Arbella Indemnity, and Covenant Insurance Company)

    800-ARBELLA (272-3552)

    Pay Online
  • American Modern Insurance Group

    800-543-2644

    Pay Online
  • Andover Companies

    Pay Online
  • Chubb Insurance Group

    Personal customers: 800-682-4822; Business customers: 800-372-4822

    Pay Online
  • Foremost Insurance Group

    800-532-4221

    Pay Online
  • New London County Mutual

    800-962-0800, ext. 4235

    Pay Online
  • Preferred Mutual Insurance Company

    800-333-7642

    Pay Online
  • Progressive/DRIVE Insurance

    800-PROGRESSIVE (776-4737)

    Pay Online
  • Plymouth Rock Assurance Company

    866-353-6292

    Pay Online
  • PURE

    888-813-7873

    Pay Online
  • Safeco Insurance

    800-332-3226

    Pay Online
  • Travelers

    800-842-5075

    Pay Online
  • United Property & Casualty Insurance Company

    800-295-8016

    Pay Online
  • Vermont Mutual Insurance Group

    800-231-7820

    Pay Online

From the Blog

  • What to Ask Your Insurance Agent During a Policy Review

    The new year is an opportunity to have a fresh start. Many people take this time to set new personal and professional goals — but it’s also a great time to review your insurance policy with your local Bearingstar Agent.

    Head to the blog for important questions to ask your agent during your 2020 review.

  • Bearingstar Charitable Fund — A Year In Review 2019

    Reflecting back on 2019, we are proud of the positive impact the Bearingstar Insurance Charitable Fund (BICF) has made for the many people and communities that we serve. Over the course of the year, BICF has made charitable donations to over 65 amazing nonprofit organizations throughout Connecticut and Massachusetts. This support is achieved through the…

  • What Will Happen if I Let My Insurance Coverage Lapse?

    There are many reasons why people may let their insurance lapse. However, it should be avoided if at all possible. Here are several reasons why it’s important to stay protected and avoid a lapse in coverage, and some tips to help you stay on track. Loss of coverage From the time your policy expires to…

From the Blog

What to Ask Your Insurance Agent During a Policy Review

The new year is an opportunity to have a fresh start. Many people take this time to set new personal and professional goals — but it’s also a great time to review your insurance policy with your local Bearingstar Agent.

Head to the blog for important questions to ask your agent during your 2020 review.

Bearingstar Charitable Fund — A Year In Review 2019

Reflecting back on 2019, we are proud of the positive impact the Bearingstar Insurance Charitable Fund (BICF) has made for the many people and communities that we serve. Over the course of the year, BICF has made charitable donations to over 65 amazing nonprofit organizations throughout Connecticut and Massachusetts. This support is achieved through the…

What Will Happen if I Let My Insurance Coverage Lapse?

There are many reasons why people may let their insurance lapse. However, it should be avoided if at all possible. Here are several reasons why it’s important to stay protected and avoid a lapse in coverage, and some tips to help you stay on track. Loss of coverage From the time your policy expires to…