Make a Payment

Make a Payment

Pay Your Insurance Bill

Below is information about paying your bill directly through your insurance carrier. If available, a billing phone number is also included should you wish to make a payment by phone instead.

If your company is not listed, if you need additional help, or if you have other billing issues, please call your local Bearingstar representative.

  • Arbella Insurance Group

    (This includes the underwriting companies of Arbella Mutual, Arbella Protection, Arbella Indemnity, and Covenant Insurance Company)

    800-ARBELLA (272-3552)

    Pay Online
  • American Modern Insurance Group

    800-543-2644

    Pay Online
  • Andover Companies

    Pay Online
  • Chubb Insurance Group

    Personal customers: 800-682-4822; Business customers: 800-372-4822

    Pay Online
  • Foremost Insurance Group

    800-532-4221

    Pay Online
  • MAPFRE

    800-562-4517

  • New London County Mutual

    800-962-0800, ext. 4235

    Pay Online
  • Preferred Mutual Insurance Company

    800-333-7642

    Pay Online
  • Progressive/DRIVE Insurance

    800-PROGRESSIVE (776-4737)

    Pay Online
  • Plymouth Rock Assurance Company

    866-353-6292

    Pay Online
  • Safeco Insurance

    800-332-3226

    Pay Online
  • Travelers

    Pay Online
  • United Property & Casualty Insurance Company

    800-295-8016

    Pay Online
  • Vermont Mutual Insurance Group

    800-231-7820

    Pay Online

From the Blog

  • 5 Scenarios Where You Should Consider Umbrella Insurance

    At Bearingstar Insurance, we believe that insurance is more than just a piece of paper, it’s peace of mind — and an umbrella insurance policy can offer just that by providing additional liability coverage beyond the limits of your home or auto insurance policies. While we’ve already covered the basics about umbrella insurance in our blog,…

  • Tips and Insights For Your New Driver

    It may seem like just yesterday that you were dropping your little one off at school, and now they’re asking for the keys to drive themselves. As a parent, putting a new driver on the road can be equally nerve wracking as it is exciting, which is why we’ve put together the following list of…

  • Home Inventory Guide — Why You Need One and How to Get Started

    It’s officially spring cleaning season! Here at Bearingstar Insurance, we think this is also a great time to make or update your home inventory. Not sure why you need one? A home inventory is a great resource to share with your local insurance agent. A comprehensive home inventory will help your agent ensure you have…

From the Blog

5 Scenarios Where You Should Consider Umbrella Insurance

At Bearingstar Insurance, we believe that insurance is more than just a piece of paper, it’s peace of mind — and an umbrella insurance policy can offer just that by providing additional liability coverage beyond the limits of your home or auto insurance policies. While we’ve already covered the basics about umbrella insurance in our blog,…

Tips and Insights For Your New Driver

It may seem like just yesterday that you were dropping your little one off at school, and now they’re asking for the keys to drive themselves. As a parent, putting a new driver on the road can be equally nerve wracking as it is exciting, which is why we’ve put together the following list of…

Home Inventory Guide — Why You Need One and How to Get Started

It’s officially spring cleaning season! Here at Bearingstar Insurance, we think this is also a great time to make or update your home inventory. Not sure why you need one? A home inventory is a great resource to share with your local insurance agent. A comprehensive home inventory will help your agent ensure you have…