Pay Your Insurance Bill

Below is information about paying your bill directly through your insurance carrier. If available, a billing phone number is also included should you wish to make a payment by phone instead. If your company is not listed, if you need additional help, or if you have other billing issues, please call your local Bearingstar representative.

Arbella Insurance Group (This includes the underwriting companies of Arbella Mutual, Arbella Protection, Arbella Indemnity, and Covenant Insurance Company) 800-ARBELLA (272-3552) Pay Online
American Modern Insurance Group 800-543-2644 Pay Online
Andover Companies Pay Online
Chubb Insurance Group Personal customers: 800-682-4822; Business customers: 800-372-4822 Pay Online
Foremost Insurance Group 800-532-4221 Pay Online
MAPFRE 800-562-4517
New London County Mutual 800-962-0800, ext. 4235 Pay Online
Preferred Mutual Insurance Company 800-333-7642 Pay Online
Progressive/DRIVE Insurance 800-PROGRESSIVE (776-4737) Pay Online
Plymouth Rock Assurance Company 866-353-6292 Pay Online
Safeco Insurance 800-332-3226 Pay Online
Travelers Pay Online
United Property & Casualty Insurance Company 800-295-8016 Pay Online
Vermont Mutual Insurance Group 800-231-7820 Pay Online